Showing posts with label Paraguay. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Paraguay. Show all posts

Thursday, April 7, 2011

US-Colombia FTA Moving Forward, Opposition Remains

Colombian President Juan Manuel Santos will be passing through Washington DC today to join President Barack Obama in formally announcing White House support for a US-Colombia free trade agreement. The creation of a so-called “Action Plan” in which Colombia promises to expand protections of trade unionists, enforce its labor laws with greater vigor, and hire as many as 480 new labor inspectors over the next four years is being hailed as the final deal maker, according to US Trade Representative Ron Kirk.

The New York Times notes that neither Kirk nor White House international economic affairs adviser, Michael Froman, would yet offer a timeline for when an actual vote on the Colombian FTA would take place in the US Congress. Some congressional Republicans see a similar deal with Panama as complimentary and may press the Obama administration to move on both deals before an actual vote is taken. The Wall Street Journal this morning quotes Rep. Dave Camp (R-MI), the House chairman of the Ways and Means Committee, who says he wants the Colombia pact to be considered along with similar EU and South Korea deals by July1. There are also, of course, domestic policy concerns this week as the Republican Congress threatens to shut down the federal government over the president’s federal budget proposal.

Thus far it seems few, if any, groups or individuals opposed to the Colombia FTA because of labor and human rights concerns have been won over by the new “action plan.” A group of six House Democrats, led by Rep. Jim McGovern (D-MA) and Rep. George Miller (D-CA), released a statement Thursday which acknowledges this is the “first time any trade agreement has taken labor rights so seriously.” But the House members say pushing the FTA through without first verifying if, how, and when violence against trade unionists declines runs counter to the spirit of the action plan:

“When so many lives are at stake, we do not believe this is a matter to be rushed to Congress until we are able to determine, including through consultation with the targets of violence and human rights violations in Colombia, whether genuine and lasting change has taken place on the ground – not just on paper, but in the reality that so adversely affects so many Colombians every single day.”

The group again directs attention back to its March 17 letter and recommendations to the President, available here and here.

Congressman Sandy Levin (D-MI), Ranking Member on the House Ways and Means Committee, expressed similar concerns Wednesday. “The Administration has achieved in its discussions with the Colombia government a number of important commitments to address serious issues regarding worker rights, violence and impunity, but more work needs to be done,” the congressman says.

The AFL-CIO, which has stayed noticeably quiet about another FTA with South Korea (the UAW has actually supported that deal), also continues to oppose the Colombia agreement, despite the Wednesday’s new labor protection proposals. “We understand that the proposed Action Plan lays out some important benchmarks in terms of increasing the level of protection for workers, addressing some flaws in the labor code, and improving enforcement of labor laws,” AFL-CIO President Richard Trumka says. But, Trumka continues:

“There is no guarantee that the terms of it will in fact lead to a reduction in violence, and no backup plan to delay implementation if the violence and impunity continue. The Action Plan is a stand-alone agreement, not connected to the benefits conferred in the trade agreement. Once the trade agreement is ratified by Congress and implemented, the U.S. government will have no leverage whatsoever to enforce its terms in the event that the terms are not implemented as agreed.”

In the past 25 years, more than 2,850 trade unionists have been murdered in Colombia. Last year, 51 trade unionists were killed in Colombia – an increase from just one year prior. Six trade unionists have been murdered so far this year, including two in just the last week. Some have noted that, should the Colombia FTA be approved, Colombia’s future, in terms of violence against labor activists, could parallel that of Guatemala. There trade union murders were brought down to zero before the passage of CAFTA in 2006 but shot back up in the years which followed. In fact, the Inter-Press Service had a good piece on the Guatemala labor situation under CAFTA yesterday, which, is worth reading next to IPS’s report report today on Colombia.

For the pro-Colombia FTA position, see Senators John Kerry (D-MA) and Max Baucus (D-MT) in the Wall Street Journal earlier in the week as well as today’s Washington Post.

Today’s bullet points:

· Juan Manuel Santos deflated speculation that he might have been reconsidering his decision to send Venezuelan drug kingpin Walid Makled back to his native Venezuela. In an interview with Univision, Santos says his position has not changed. Walid Makled will be extradited to Venezuela, despite the frustration of some in the US.

· News about the advance of a US-Colombia FTA comes on the same day the Mexican Senate also ratified an expanded free trade pact with Colombia. The two countries originally signed an FTA in 1996, which, at the time, also included Venezuela (Venezuela withdrew in 2006). EFE reports: The agreement will open up the Mexican market for Colombian crackers, citric acid, sodium and calcium citrate, palm oil, pork rinds for microwave ovens and cigarettes, among other products.” The deal, however, continues to limit the entry of Colombian dairy products and coffee into the Mexican market and prohibits exports of Colombian beef to Mexico. News also this morning that a deal integrating the stock exchanges of Colombia, Peru, and Chile will go into effect on May 30. Shannon O’Neil at CFR comments on that, as well as a separate FTA expected to be signed between the three countries, plus Mexico, on May 2, and compares to the ALBA bloc.

· In Brazil, AFP reports that agricultural interests are demanding the government expand the country’s “agricultural frontier” by revising the country’s 1965 forestry law. Environmental groups are opposing the measure.

· In Mexico, the LA Times highlights a series of anti-crime marches which took place in cities around the country Wednesday. TIME, meanwhile, explores the proposal of poet Javier Sicilia, one of the demonstrations’ organizers: that a pact be made between the government and Mexican cartels to try to put an end to out-of-control violence. Mexican historian Lorenzo Meyer tells the magazine such a discussion is long-overdue. UNAM’s John Ackerman, meanwhile, says Mexicans have stopped buying the government’s line that “things have to get worse before they get better.” This as Mexican investigators discovered a new mass grave in Tamaulipas Thursday, filled with at least 59 bodies. The grave was found just a short distance from the ranch were 72 migrants were massacred last summer. Authorities were in the area investigating other very troubling reports of individuals being dragged off buses and abducted by gunmen. AP reports.

· Outgoing Haitian president Rene Preval was at the UN Wednesday, criticizing the Security Council for dragging its heels in transforming the MINUSTAH peacekeeping mission into a development mission. Seen as detached and absent in Haiti for much of the last year, Preval seems to have finally found his voice, challenging the UNSC to consider the effectiveness of its interventions that “have practically led to 11 years of military presence in a country that has no war.” Edmund Mulet, head of the UN mission in Haiti tells the AP he is in agreement. “We all agree with Preval. This is what we all want. This is what we all need — for the peacekeeping mission to leave Haiti.” But Mulet says his timeline for departure is somewhere around 2015. CEPR points out that South America, through UNASUR and the South American Defense Council, may be pushing for the mission to end more rapidly.

· The Carter Center has posted Jimmy Carter’s Cuba trip report. Geoff Thale at WOLA comments on the trip, as well as an announcement by DOS just two days after Carter’s return that it, through USAID, will continue to support – to the tune of $20 million – controversial “human rights and civil society programs” on the island. “It is these very “regime change” programs,” says Thale, “that landed U.S. citizen Alan Gross in jail well over a year ago.”

· Portugal looks like it will not take Brazil’s advice, announcing today that it will accept an almost $129 billion bailout from the IMF and EU. The Wall Street Journal reports.

· In Argentina, Cristina Fernandez de Kirchner is reassigning some 1200 federal police officers to Buenos Aires amid rising complaints of crime insecurity in the capital. In Bolivia, Evo Morales has authorized the Bolivian military to operate along the border in an attempt to combat “illicit” activities, including narco-trafficking. In Paraguay, Fernando Lugo, meanwhile, has put his military in charge of a new anti-mosquito campaign intended to stem growing concerns about dengue.

· Reuters reports on major clashes between campesinos and security forces at Southern Copper’s Tia Maria mine in Peru this week. The campesinos involved say they will boycott the presidential election if the mining project there is not brought to a halt.

· And finally Jo-Marie Burt and Coletta Youngers at Foreign Policy in Focus on Peru’s elections this Sunday, specifically Ollanta Humala’s rise. Also worth reading, a recent interview with CIDDH director, Ricardo Soberón, who, on a personal basis, has been advising the Humala campaign on drug policy.

Tuesday, February 8, 2011

Toward a Mesoamerican Security Corridor?

US Assistant Secretary of State for International Narcotics and Law Enforcement Affairs (INL) William R. Brownfield is in El Salvador today, the second stop on a four-country tour through Mesoamerica. Brownfield arrives in San Salvador from Guatemala where he met yesterday with top officials there – among them President Alvaro Colom. He travels next to Honduras and then Colombia, a country in which he recently served as US ambassador.

More than any other, the issue of “security” unites the assistant secretary’s schedule this week. In Guatemala, Brownfield visited the municipality of Mixco to meet with its mayor, Amilcar Rivera, about a U.S.-supported “Model Police Precinct” program operating there. In Honduras, the State Dept. says Brownfield will be meeting with the country’s Secretary of State for Security, Oscar Alvarez, and will participate in a Bilateral Central American Regional Security Initiative (Merida/CARSI) Task Force chaired by U.S. Ambassador Hugo Llorens and Honduran President Porfirio Lobo Sosa. And in Colombia meetings are planned with the country’s new top prosecutor, Viviane Morales, the Commander of the Armed Forces, Admiral Edgar Cely, and Director of the Colombian National Police General, Oscar Naranjo. The objective, says DOS: to “explore avenues for enhanced regional cooperation” and “take into account lessons learned in Colombia.”

But with President Obama planning to visit El Salvador in March, Brownfield’s stopover today in El Salvador may be of most significance. (Assistant Secretary of State for Western Hemisphere Affairs, Arturo Valenzuela, also plans to visit the country next week ahead of President Obama’s visit). The official schedule says Brownfield will meet with Salvadoran Vice Minister of Justice Henry Campos, Prison Director Douglas Moreno, Police Commissioner Carlos Ascensio, and Attorney General Romeo Barahona to discuss ongoing efforts to build law enforcement capacity in El Salvador. The US assistant secretary will also be visiting the Transnational Anti-Gang headquarters and the US-run International Law Enforcement Academy (ILEA), in the news last week further south in the region.

In few countries – even in the increasingly violent Central America – have issues of citizen (in) security become a more high profile issue than in El Salvador. Worrying numbers from a poll published by Salvador’s El Faro last week revealed that if both economic and security concerns continue to ineffectively addressed, 45.6% of Salvadorans would support a military takeover of the government. The highly respected editor of El Faro, Carlos Dada, commenting on those results in opinion piece last week, called organized crime, insecurity, and poverty the “the greatest threats” to El Salvador today. And his words demonstrate the urgency gripping many:

“With the advance of organized crime we are rapidly approaching a crossroads: either we consolidate the State or we leave it for someone else to destroy, in the name of the country, but seizing citizen desperation, since it can now be seen that many do not believe in democracy if their most urgent demands are not satisfied.”

But questions remain about how such concerns will be addressed – as well as by whom. The US and the Salvadoran military, for starters, have become two increasingly active pieces of the security puzzle. In mid-January, US ambassador to El Salvador, Mari Carmen Aponte, made what some are calling an unprecedented television appeal to Salvadoran Attorney General Romeo Barahona, requesting that he sign off on approving the creation of new $5 million, US-backed wiretapping center in the country. (The attorney general finally agreed on Jan. 29). For his part, President Mauricio Funes, also late last month, indicated that the army would remain deployed “indefinitely” to handle public security duties.

Meanwhile, after both Bill Brownfield and Arturo Valenzuela leave San Salvador, President Mauricio Funes heads to Colombia. On his agenda there, according to early reports, will be talks about how Colombia might provide assistance and expertise to the Salvadoran government in its fight against organized crime.

No evidence yet to suggest El Salvador is seeking the sort of direct training which Colombia appears to now be providing to Mexico, but – for better or worse – that may be a sign of things to come.

To other stories:

· On Colombia, Adam Isacson, in his Just the Facts podcast this week, has details about multiple FARC hostage releases that are expected to occur in the coming days. As Adam discusses, the FARC have asked President Santos – in one of the more explicit mentions of possible dialogue in recent memory – to “seize the opportunity” and move toward some sort of peace talks that would “allow for a political solution” to the decades-long conflict. Aiding in this week’s releases will be the International Red Cross, the Brazilian military, and ex-Colombian Senator Piedad Cordoba. The latter has gone so far as to say that, should this week’s operations be successful, all of the FARC’s remaining hostages could be freed by the middle of the year.

· In neighboring Venezuela, a new Consultores 21 poll suggests a significant decline in President Hugo Chavez’s popularity. According to a Nuevo Herald report on the poll (conducted between 19 Nov and 6 Dec 2010), 63% of Venezuelans believe the situation in the country has worsened while 56% of respondents call the president’s management of the country “poor.” Full survey results available here.

· Brazilian Foreign Minister Antonio Patriota was also in Venezuela Monday, meeting with his counterpart Nicolas Maduro to discuss issues of regional integration. The meeting was the first between representatives of the two countries since Dilma Rousseff took power on Jan. 1. Issues of agricultural development, housing, banking, and telecommunications were all discussed, says Infolatam. Brazil’s foreign minister also said he would continue advocating for Venezuela’s entry into Mercosur.

· Meanwhile, there is new speculation that Mercosur may soon be starting talks with the European Union about a major trade deal. The executive secretary of the Economic Commission for Latin America, Alicia Bárcena, was in Brussels last week to discuss ways of strengthening economic relations between the Latin America and the EU. And this week the EU’s top trade official, Karel de Gutch is in Paraguay to meet with President Fernando Lugo before continuing on to Uruguay. According to Mercopress, a possible EU-Mercosur trade deal was among the items discussed.

· On the issue of trade in the US, President Barack Obama reiterated his commitment to free trade deals with Colombia and Panama while speaking to members of the US Chamber of Commerce in Washington Monday – although the AP notes the president was short on specifics, or a timeline on those pending trade deals. As the Washington Post notes, the mention was followed by a Senate floor speech by Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) urging the president to “do more than promise to ‘pursue’” the Colombia and Panama deals.

· US Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner, in his first visit to Brazil Monday, met with President Dilma Rousseff, and the Wall Street Journal suggests that US and Brazil may start “speaking with a common voice” about an undervalued Chinese currency at the next meetings of the G-20.

· Brazil’s former president, Lula da Silva made the 2011 World Social Forum in Senegal his first international trip since leaving office just over one month ago. Página 12 has more on the re-emergence of Lula the fiery trade union leader, who had strong words of criticism for the world’s richest nations, the IMF, and the economic prescriptions that made up the Washington Consensus. About the WSF, in particular, Lula da Silva: “These are our chance to meet and discuss the ideas that others say have been lost. In the Forum we come together to say that another world is both possible and necessary. This is a dream that we will never abandon.”

· In Rio, the AP yesterday on the takeover of nine more favelas by state security forces Sunday, apparently with little resistance.

· In Mexico, the LA Times reports that the PAN has won the governorship of the state of Baja California Sur – but, strangely enough, with a candidate, Marcos Covarrubias, who only recently defected from the left-leaning PRD.

· In Haiti, the AFP reports a diplomatic passport has been issued by the Haitian government to Jean-Bertrand Aristide. “The passport was issued on Monday. All the formalities have been completed,” an unnamed official tells the news agency. Aristide’s lawyer, who some reports say was in Haiti this weekend filing necessary paperwork for the passport, says that, if it’s true, he is still awaiting confirmation from the government. Asked if Aristide would be back in Haiti soon, Ira Kurzban tells the AFP, “I think we're getting closer, but we're not there yet.” Meanwhile, the term of outgoing President Rene Preval has been officially extended 3-months, until May 14. As the AP notes, an emergency law passed by members of Preval's former party in an expiring Senate allows him to remain in office for up to three more months because his 2006 inauguration was delayed. And debate continues over the validity of the CEP’s decision last week to move Michel Martelly into a second-round runoff against Mirlande Manigat. In a statement Monday, the Boston-based Institute for Justice and Democracy in Haiti says the CEP did not officially approve a runoff vote as only four of eight CEP officials actually signed on to the decision last week. More from the CEPR.

· Amnesty International says a Honduran human rights lawyer with the Association for a More Just Society has received new threats against his life, via text message. While at The Nation, Greg Grandin comments on on-going concerns about human rights and democracy in the country, as well as the “restoration” of the old cold war alliance between the landed aristocracy and death squads, today “updated to serve the new bio-fuel economy.”

· Amnesty International also has a new statement urging the release of political prisoners in Cuba.

· In Colombia, the Miami Herald reports on the illegal gold mining by guerrilla groups and organized crime syndicates while IPS reports on growing social movement mobilization against large scale mining.

· And finally, Infolatam previews the upcoming electoral calendar across the region.

Tuesday, January 4, 2011

Grandchildren of Cain: Lat Am Violence, Old and New

In a piece over the holiday break, AFP noted murders rose in both number and viciousness across Latin America in 2010. The primary perpetrators, according to the report: narcotraffickers and gangs who have made insecurity the “principal worry” in the region. Benjamin Cuéllar, director of the Human Rights Institute at the Universidad Centroamericana in El Salvador tells AFP that the region has become one in which both “slow and violent death” has been “transnationalized.” Over the last decade, he says, Latin America has registered homicide rates which are no less than double the figures seen on any other continent.

In the US, there’s little doubt that Mexico’s violence – often an indiscriminate corollary of the drug wars – has received the most significant coverage over the last year. And for good reason. 2010 was Mexico’s bloodiest since Felipe Calderon called in the military to combat drug cartels in 2006. According to official statistics, as many as 15,000 were murdered in 2010 (over 30,000 since 2006) – heinous deaths and the effects torture often captured on video and distributed on the internet. According to AFP’s Sofia Miselem, the late Nazario Moreno, the now former leader of the messianic drug gang La Familia Michoacana, had ritualized death by writing a “bible” for his followers that detailed how to decapitate and burn the bodies of victims while suggesting mangled body parts be left in public places. Following the killing of Moreno and a November letter purporting some in the group were even willing to disband completely, the AP this week reports that La Familia has declared a one-month halt to its violent operations. Mexican President Felipe Calderon took that news – and the beginning of a new year – to announce that his government’s security strategy has yielded “historic results.” So much successful has the administration been, the Government Secretariat, Defense Secretariat, Navy Secretariat, Public Safety Secretariat and Attorney General’s Office said in a joint statement released Sunday, that its strategy deserves to be expanded “with the participation of the state governments and municipalities.”

On Monday, the AP reports, the severed head of a young man – somewhere between 25 and 30 years old, investigators estimate – was found hanging from a bridge in Tijuana, a city which has been heralded by the Mexican government as illustrative of its “success.” A threatening message nearby suggested more violence could be expected.

Writing in the New York Times from Mexico City, Alma Guillermoprieto’s focus is Tamaulipas where the Zetas are believed to have murdered 72 migrants, most from Central America, last August. “Equipped with an alarming array of smuggled weapons and financed by illegal drug sales,” she says the Zetas are now a “nationwide organization.” The groups remains the primary suspects in the disappearance of another group of Central American migrants shortly before Christmas in Oaxaca. But given years of movement into Central America – only now drawing attention through a state of siege in Northern Guatemala – the Zetas “local franchises” now seem to extend well-beyond Mexico’s national borders.

In 2010, Violence also loomed large south of the Mesoamerican corridor. As Boz notes, Venezuela (with Honduras) – not Mexico – competed for the title of the region’s (if not the world’s) most violent country. According to the Observatorio de la Violence (OVV), Venezuela, with a ¼ the total population of Mexico, registered nearly 17,600 homicides in 2010. The significant difference, according to the OVV’s Roberto Briceno León: the “generalized nature” of violence in his country. “In other places, violence is linked to organized crime,” he says. In Venezuela it’s not the FARC or La Familia or the Comando Primero in Sao Paulo. Rather it’s “everyday, disorganized crime.”

If Latin America’s violence was once particular because of its “planned, deliberate” nature, as author Tina Rosenberg once suggested, violence Venezuela may represent something quite new.

To be sure, “planned” violence continues. The murder of journalists, for example, has become the quintessential example of “politically motivated” murder. In 2010, according to EFE, at least 35 journalists were killed around Latin America, making it the most dangerous region in the world to be practicing the profession. Mexico, with 14 journalist murders, led regional statistics. It was followed by Honduras with nine journalist killings, but before the year ended, a tenth was killed as 2010 came to a close. Many of those killings can be linked to a more “traditional” definition of politics, namely the 2009 coup. According to Human Rights Watch, if journalists, human rights defenders, and political activists are combined, the number of post coup, “politically motivated” murders jumps to 18 [19 if the murder of late December murder of La Ceiba journalist Henry Suazo is included].

As a point of comparison, there were nine journalists killed in Iraq in 2009.

Returning to Mexico:

· An alarming report from El Diario (with an English recap at All Voices) which seems to reveal a great deal more about the expanded role of the DEA in intelligence operations across the region. According to El Diario, DEA agents are working undercover in Juarez as “fortune tellers, peddlers, and city bus drivers,” conducting wiretaps, and sending intelligence gathered back to the US by way of Mexico City. The story comes from an anonymous source who claims to be one of many undercover spies planted in Juarez by the DEA. That source tells the paper that at least two agents have been murdered so far. The credibility of the source and his information, says El Diario, has been confirmed by agents and former agents from the DEA in El Paso and New Mexico. From the All Voices recap, which quotes from El Diario:

“Everything he [the informant says] is plausible, but what is amazing is that it’s very dangerous to be saying those things.”

· At the New York Review of Books blog, Lilia Schwarcz comments on violence in Brazil, particular its depiction in the media as unique to Rio’s favelas. According to Schwarcz, the problem may be much more pervasive; the struggle against it a longer, grimmer one than is usually discussed:

“[T]he prevailing black-and-white logic—according to which the drug trade is exclusive to favela life and doesn’t have implications for the police, politicians, or the population as a whole—is nonsense. It is now clear that drug-trafficking has been as omnipresent among certain corrupt police squads as it has in the favelas.”

· From TIME, John Otis on how land reform – and the extension of property rights to displaced Colombian farmers – may be one part of a broader resolution to the country’s on-going violence. Speaking to TIME, Colombian agriculture minister Juan Camilo Restrepo says the Santos government is now convinced that “if there's no rational and just solution to the land problem in Colombia we will never achieve a lasting peace.” To empower small farmers, Otis writes, “President Juan Manuel Santos launched a fast-track program in which government workers travel to isolated towns to hand out land titles.”

· The usual beginning of the year calls for finishing free trade agreements with Colombia and Panama from former White House National Drug Policy Office spokesman Robert Weiner, in the Miami Herald and the Inter-American Dialogue’s Michael Shifter, in El Colombiano.

· State Dept. spokesman PJ Crowley suggested Monday that ambassadorial nominee Larry Palmer would not be re-nominated to fill a vacancy in the US embassy in Caracas. The back and forth with reporters below, and more from the Latin American Herald Tribune:

QUESTION: Are you going to think in another possibility, I mean, that the – no Ambassador Palmer, but another possibility, another ambassador, another designee?

MR. CROWLEY: I mean, that – these are issues that we will be evaluating with the new year. I believe that Larry Palmer’s nomination formally expired with the end of the last Congress, so among the issues that we’ll be evaluating is what to do in light of that and the step that Venezuela unfortunately took.

QUESTION: So his status is that he’s no longer the nominee?

MR. CROWLEY: We will have to re-nominate an ambassador candidate.

· A new survey from Fundacion Progresa in Santiago de Chile, reveals the failures of anti-drug campaigns targeting young people in Chile. The full results of the survey – conducted at 19 universities around Chile – can be found here. The head of the recently formed left-of-center Partido Progresista, Marco Enríquez-Ominami, appears to have joined Fundación Progresa for the survey’s release. More from Eduardo Vergara Bolbarán, director of Fundación Progresa, in Chile’s La Tercera.

· Chile, along with Paraguay, will be the next two Latin American countries to offer diplomatic recognition to Palestine, says Haaretz. The two countries join Uruguay, Brazil, Argentina, and Bolivia in making recent announcements on the matter. Ecuador and Venezuela preceded those countries. More from IPS on this most recent South American regional diplomatic effort.

· A series of opinions on the on-going electoral uncertainties in Haiti. In the Miami Herald, Nicole Philips of the Institute for Justice and Democracy in Haiti, along with Nicolas Alberto Pascal, call on the Haitian government to replace the Provisional Electoral Council and hold new, open, and fair elections. At the end of December, the New York Times said an agreement between the Preval government and the OAS which would allow the OAS to re-examine Nov. 28 results provided the possibility of an exit to the crisis. Meanwhile, a series of Haiti dispatches in the new issue of Mother Jones, from journalist Mac McClelland.

· Finally, Lanny Davis, (in)famous amongst Latin Americanists for his representation of the Honduran coup regime in 2009, is back in the news as 2011 begins. In late December, Davis gave a priceless interview to Salon.com about his most recent client, the unsavory regime of Laurent Gbagbo in the Ivory Coast. Last Thursday, the New York Times Ginger Thompson followed that up with a report that the “front man for the dark side” (the Times words) had withdrawn from his $100,000-a-month contract with the Ivory Coast last Wednesday. And now Narco News brings us back to Honduras after getting its hands on a Nov. 2010 letter and memo from Lanny Davis to Honduran President Pepe Lobo and Honduran ambassador Jorge Ramón Hernández Alcerro, spelling out the terms of his new gig working for the Honduran embassy. His objectives, according to the memo, are two-fold: continued lobbying of the Obama administration and Congress on the Honduran government’s behalf and mounting a “communications strategy” targeting “US and global media” to get a “more positive narrative about Honduras” into “multiple media outlets.”

Friday, December 17, 2010

Mercosur's Economics of Regional Integration

Mercosur leaders are in Foz de Igaucu, Brazil today where, according to outgoing Brazilian foreign minister Celso Amorim, member states have agreed to new set of trade agreements between the South American bloc and Australia, New Zealand, Syria, and the recently recognized Palestinian territories. Mercopress says Argentine foreign minister Hector Timerman has initiated talks with representatives from the United Arab Emirates about a similar deal between Mercosur and the Cooperation Council of the Gulf. AFP reports on the signing of a new preferential tariff deal with several developing nations, among them India. There have been discussions about creating a new “High Representative” post within the bloc. And, according to Bloomberg, there was also talk Thursday, initiated by Brazil and Argentina, about bolstering economic and political ties between Mercosur and Cuba, perhaps going so far as to bring the island into the regional trade bloc as an associate member.

Also of significance in Foz de Iguacu: agreement by permanent Mercosur members Brazil, Argentina, Paraguay, and Uruguay to draft common investment guarantees, anti-trust laws, and a single policy on the automotive industry in addition to renewed pledges made last June to “streamline” Mercosur’s “common external tariff” so as to ensure the free circulation of goods between members by 2014. Mercopress, on the optimism about regional economic integration, at least in the Southern Cone, at the present moment:

“Mercosur this year regained some of its momentum and regional leaders again are speaking of creating something similar to the European Union in South America.”

Similar sentiments from the Inter-Press Service’s reporting on the summit:

“For the first time in decades, there seems to be a reversal of roles [between the EU and South America]. The global crisis is posing serious challenges for the EU, while the South American bloc has recovered with a fiscal solidity and trade options that it did not possess when facing previous external shocks.”

This week’s meeting also comes amidst news that trade within the regional bloc, including with current associate member Venezuela, will hit an all-time high of over $40 billion in 2010. Responding to those numbers, Argentine Industries Minister, Debora Giorgi, called 2010 a “transcendental” year for the “consolidation” of the Market of the South. Interestingly, manufactured goods will make up 70% of that intra-Mercosur trade. Speaking with IPS, Luis Groppa, regional head of the Macroeconomic Monitoring Support Project, on what these changes are beginning to produce and what member states still desire:

“The development gap is narrowing, but what we seek is not only greater economic growth in quantitative terms, but growth with social inclusion in order to reduce inequality, which is the big challenge.”

Total exports from the bloc to the rest of the world are also estimated to rise to $230 billion this year, a 24% increase since 2009, and yet another sign of the region’s speedy economic recovery. Meanwhile, the bloc’s international reserves holdings currently stand at $200 billion dollars – equivalent to 13% of regional GDP. That, says IPS, represents “an unprecedented amount.”

In other issues related to the region’s rising international presence:

· News that right-leaning Chilean president, Sebastian Pinera is currently deliberating whether or not to follow Argentina, Uruguay, and Brazil in recognizing an independent Palestine state within 1967 borders. U.S. Under Secretary for Political Affairs, William J. Burns recently criticized Argentina and Brazil’s recognition of Palestine, calling the move “premature.”

· EFE reports that Costa Rica and Nicaragua have accepted a regional mediation offer from Mexico and Guatemala aimed at resolving the on-going border dispute between the two countries. The new round of mediation was announced by Guatemalan President Alvaro Colom before the inauguration of the 36th Summit of Heads of State and Government of the Central American Integration System (SICA) taking place in Belize.

· Former Guatemalan interior minister, Carlos Vielmann, was rearrested in Spain on Thursday after turning himself into Spanish authorities. As CNN notes, Vielmann is wanted for his alleged role in series of extrajudicial killings at a Guatemalan prison in 2006. Those killings have become a target of the UN-backed anti-impunity commission in Guatemala, CICIG.

· BBC Mundo, which did a series on organized crime in Guatemala yesterday, does the same for El Salvador today. In a video report, BBC Mundo discusses the growing presence of Mexican cartels in the country while a written piece looks at evidence of collusion between local gangs like the Maras and transnational trafficking groups, like the Zetas. InSight, meanwhile, looks at how a controversial anti-gang law in El Salvador has gone unimplemented, three months after its passage. And the Economist on how, even amidst growing worries of citizen insecurity and economic problems, Mauricio Funes remains one of the region’s most popular leaders.

· InSight also directs attention to a new report from the Washington Office on Latin America and the Miguel Agustin Pro Juarez Human Rights Center (Center Prodh), on violence and rights abuses against mostly Central American migrants traveling through Mexico (“A Dangerous Journey Through Mexico”). Luis Arriaga, the Director of the Center Prodh:

“The failure to punish authorities and others involved in kidnappings and attacks against migrants has created a climate that perpetuates more abuses. The Mexican government's own reporting states that only two people have been sentenced for a crime against migrants in the past two years; this number pales in comparison to the magnitude of the abuses taking place.”

· Also on Mexico, the Washington Post says the country’s attorney general, Arturo Chavez Chavez, has requested Interpol’s assistance in tracking down and arresting lawmaker Julio Cesar Godoy, a federal deputy suspected of laundering money for La Familia. Godoy had his immunity revoked by the Mexican Congress in a 384 to 2 vote earlier this week. He has since split town.

· The Wall Street Journal looks at growing apprehension about Mexico and its drug violence on the part of major international companies.

· The Economist this week offers its thoughts on what some have called Mexico’s “Whack-a-Mole” strategy for going after top cartel kingpins. Like many others, it’s pessimistic:

“A temporary increase in violence may be a price worth paying to dismantle powerful gangs. But Mexicans are tiring of the war. In October a plurality considered the campaign a ‘failure’ for the first time, according to Mitofsky, a polling firm. Leaked cables from the American embassy report that a senior Mexican official cautioned that the fight would be hard to continue unless results were seen within 18 months. That was 14 months ago.”

· The CS Monitor on the land reform in Bolivia, one of only two or three South American countries (the report says Brazil and Venezuela also continue land reform projects) who continue land redistribution programs. As the report indicates, the Morales government’s continuation of land reform is an attempt to carry out the mandate of agrarian reform begun in 1953.

· As Lula da Silva prepares to leave office with a “dizzying” approval rating of 87%, incoming Brazilian President Dilma Rousseff has named current deputy foreign minister, Antonio Patriota as her new foreign minister, replacing Celso Amorim. Current defense minister Nelson Jobim, meanwhile, will stay on into the next administration.

· Finally, Cuba. In the Baltimore Sun, the New America Foundation’s Anya Landau French and Arturo Lopez-Levy on why Alan Gross is a victim of US policy to Cuba. In the Miami Herald, Marifeli Perez-Stable on Guillermo Farinas and what she sees as a lack of international solidarity with Cuba’s dissidents. And Wikileaks has released – and the Miami Herald reports on – new diplomatic cables that indicate Raul Castro sought to open up a back channel with the White House in late 2009. The Spanish, namely the country’s ambassador in Havana, Manuel Cacho and foreign minister, Miguel Angel Moratinos, were the alleged go-betweens. However, according to the documents, Sec. of State Hillary Clinton and the US’s top diplomat in Havana, Jonathan Farrar, both showed little interest in creating a new back-channel for direct negotiations.

Wednesday, December 15, 2010

"Enabling" the Bolivarian Accelerator?

The Venezuelan National Assembly has given initial approval to an “enabling law” which would allow President Hugo Chavez to govern by decree for one year. As Reuters notes, during his 11 years in power, Chavez has been granted such special powers three times before. This time the president maintains “fast track” authority is needed in the wake of major floods that have killed 40 and left 140,000 Venezuelans homeless.

A second and final vote on the “enabling law” (“Ley Habilitante”: full text here) is expected to occur no later than Thursday.

In a piece Monday, Frank Jack Daniel of Reuters provides a concise appraisal of the “enabling law,” as well as a preview of what sorts of legislation Chavez might “fast track.” “An emergency housing law allowing the government to seize disused land in cities, new rules to regulate the Internet and a law that will take some profits from banks are among bills currently on the parliamentary agenda,” he writes, although it is not entirely clear what might lie beyond those bills. [The Times coverage highlights the emphasis Chavez has placed on new housing legislation following devastating floods while Reuters also says a new value-added sales tax is expected to be passed – by decree or otherwise – to help fund reconstruction]. Reuters also notes that the president appears to be “within his rights” to request such powers, “at least during the next three weeks.” The principal risk, Daniel argues, is a “tarnishing” of the president’s “democratic credentials” if he chooses to use decree powers well into the next parliament.

It’s that issue which has the Venezuelan opposition furious. After proposing a one-year term for presidential decree powers, the principal opposition coalition, the Mesa de la Unidad Democrática (MUD), among others, released a statement Tuesday rejecting the passage of the enabling law. According to the New York Times the issue has opened up a “new” – albeit not unexpected – “phase of tension between the president and his critics.” While still in the minority, the opposition will take over a larger share of seats [66 of 165 seats] in the new parliament, which takes office Jan. 5.

Given the highly polarized nature of politics Venezuela – emanating both from the opposition and the ruling party – it’s often a challenge to see what’s at stake in debates such as this one. But since this will be the fourth time Chavez will assume special decree powers, history does offer some speculative clues.

As the New York Times notes, most recently, in 2008, Chavez used a decree to controversially “name regional political leaders with separate budgets, offsetting gains by the opposition in state and municipal elections.” Beginning in January 2007, Chavez exercised “decree powers” for a total of 18 months, significantly longer than what is currently being requesting (and, if I remember correctly, there was no particular “national emergency” at that time which provided special justification). The most active period of those 18 months were its final days when 26 new laws were enacted, many of which were parts of the constitutional reform voted down in 2007. In total, 67 new laws were implemented over the course of those 18 months. Among them, wrote Venezuelanalayis in 2008, were new laws on “monetary conversion, the nationalization of the steel, cement, oil, and electricity sectors, an intelligence law that was later revoked, the promotion of small and medium-sized industries and other new types of state or community-run social production enterprises, the reorganization of the national armed forces, the reorganization of national finance institutions, reforms of public administration laws aimed at trimming back bureaucracy and eliminating corruption, price controls, agricultural development policy, and food supply chain controls.” [More details about the 2007-2008 “enabling” period, from the Venezuelan Embassy in Washington]:

It’s also useful to look at critiques of that period, of which there were a variety. Shortly after the 2007 enabling law was passed sociologist Greg Wilpert did a good job explaining why the enabling law was not illegal and not, in and of itself, destructive of checks and balances. But at the same time, Wilpert argued it did create a significant “contradiction.” Wilpert: “One should note, for example, that there is a contradiction between Chavez wanting to pass laws for introducing more participatory democracy and his doing so in a way that bypasses the democratically elected legislature.” [From a position more critical of Chavez, a very similar critique was offered in 2008 by historian Margarita Lopez Maya]. Perhaps the greatest danger then, argued Wilpert, was that it would fuel polarization by “pushing even moderate critics of Chavez into the camp that believes Chavez is heading towards dictatorship.” Many of these same critiques seem to still hold true today.

Also on Venezuela:

· The Inter-Press Service reports on growing worries among some human rights activists that social protest is becoming “criminalized” in the country. The piece begins with the case of Rubén González, secretary general of the ironworkers union in Venezuela, who has spent the last year in prison after leading a 15 day strike in August 2009 to demand the” payment of wages in accordance with a collective bargaining agreement.” The protest ended with a settlement – but also González’s detainment for alleged “agavillamiento” (criminal association), instigation to commit crimes, restricting freedom to work and violating designated security areas. The human rights group PROVEA tells IPS that González’s case is one of many similar ones documented in the group’s annual report on human rights in Venezuela, which includes a special study on protests from 2000-2010. Here’s lawyer Mariana Belalba, the lead author of the study:

“The criminalisation of social protests, using the justice system, has been growing since 2005. At present, more than 2,400 people are facing prosecution for exercising their right to peaceful protest.”

According to Provea, some 19,250 protests were recorded over the decade, 71 percent of which were organized to demand social and economic rights, 26 percent for civil and political rights, and the remainder for unspecified purposes.

· In Colombia, the country’s lower house has taken the first step in approving a much-discussed law on reparations for victims of violent conflict in the country. The bill has been modified, however, to allow only those who were victims of post-1990 violence to be compensated – a decision which the left-leaning Polo Democratico rejects. The current bill also grants “equal rights to victims of violence committed by illegal armed groups and state agents,” says Colombia Reports.

· Colombia Reports also has more on new joint Colombian-Venezuelan anti-drug operations along the countries’ shared border. From Al-Jazeera, a report on new Wikileak documents which say Colombian President Alvaro Uribe seriously considered sending Colombian troops into Venezuela to capture FARC leaders in 2008. Uribe confirmed those reports, by way of Twitter, yesterday: “Reply to Wikileaks: I proposed it and I did it: to protect Colombians you must capture the terrorists where ever they are.”

· From Guatemala, an excellent report from IPS on the recent wave of attacks being made against the UN’s International Commission Against Impunity (CICIG) by members of that country’s political and economic establishment. As IPS reports, recent CICIG investigations have gone after officials in the administration of former president Oscar Berger (2004-2008) – among them former Interior minister Carlos Vielman and Alejandro Giammettei, a former director of the Guatemalan prison system. The former was in Spanish custody for a number of weeks but was recently released after the Guatemalan government failed to initiate extradition proceedings. CICIG head, Francisco Dall’Anese has slammed the government for its inaction, accusing it of “obstructing the former minister's return to Guatemala.”

· In Paraguay, a deal which appeared to have won over the opposition into voting for Venezuela’s entry into Mercosur appears to have again collapsed, according to EFE.

· Meanwhile, the regional body will be meeting later this week in Foz de Iguazu, says Mercopress, and may decide on the creation of a “High Representative” post within the organization. That person would “create consensus” among member states and be the day-to-day face of the bloc.

· Mercosur countries saw some the best economic growth performance in 2010, according to the Economic Commission for Latin America’s preliminary annual survey of the region. Overall, the study shows Latin America and the Caribbean growing by 6% in 2010, up from a 1.9% decline in 2009. Paraguay, Uruguay, Peru, and Argentina are among 2010’s regional growth leaders. Only Haiti and Venezuela saw growth continue to decline in 2010. More from The Guardian.

· The New York Times and Wall Street Journal both report on the Mexican lower house’s decision to strip congressman Julio César Godoy of immunity and his legislative duties – a decision the Times says could lead to the congressman’s arrest and trial for allegedly laundering millions of dollars for La Familia. Investigators must now try to locate Godoy.

· At the excellent new resource for organized crime watchers, InSight, Steven Dudley writes on why La Familia will continue to hold power in Michoacan after the killing of one of its leaders, Nazario Moreno, last weekend.

· And finally, in Haiti, the AP reports on a new proposal from presidential contender Michel Martelly to resolve the current electoral crisis: a re-do of the Nov. 28 elections, with all candidates participating, after the replacement of the Provisional Electoral Council (CEP). More from the Miami Herald.