Thursday, October 15, 2009

Deal or No Deal? A Possible Third Candidate May Assume Honduran Presidency

Deal or no deal? From Honduras, mixed signals came out of Wednesday’s round of negotiations as Zelaya representative Victor Meza told reporters that a “tentative deal” had been struck with the Micheletti regime [Spain’s El País prints the more complete statements issued by Zelaya and Micheletti negotiators about having/not having reached some sort of agreement Wednesday]. However, as the New York Times and many others write, soon thereafter, Mr. Micheletti insisted no formal agreement had yet been struck. Mr. Micheletti remarked late Wednesday: “As I understand it, Zelaya is asking that Congress determine if he can return or not. But it is the Supreme Court that has to decide.” Dialogue now is expected to continue on through Thursday—the original deadline set by Mr. Zelaya for signing an accord.

Beyond the confusion, there are some emerging details, however. According to the Wall Street Journal Meza said the opposing sides “have agreed on one unified text that will be discussed and analyzed by President Zelaya and [interim President Roberto] Micheletti.” He went on to add, in very careful language, that “I wouldn't talk of an end to the crisis, but of an exit, yes.” One deputy in the Honduran Congress later spoke to the paper, saying there’s now “95%” consensus. The deputy, Antonio Rivera, added that the only thing that remains is deciding “who would be president,” suggesting that person would be neither Mr. Micheletti nor Mr. Zelaya. And then he offered more details to the WSJ. Rivera revealed that Mr. Micheletti has suggested that José Alfredo Saavedra, his own successor as president of the Honduran Congress take over the presidency through November elections while Mr. Zelaya offered up Victor Meza himself to be the country’s temporary president. Moreover, the WSJ says this idea—that neither Mr. Zelaya nor Micheletti continue on as president—came from the Zelaya negotiating team, which also proposed the temporary governing body be composed of the presidents of the Congress and the president of the Supreme Court.

There was also optimism in the words of one prominent coup backer, Gen Romeo Vázquez, who told Honduran radio Wednesday that “We have advanced a lot. We are almost at the end of the crisis.” Yet again, the OAS spoke of “optimism” as well. “I don't want to be excessively optimistic ... but I think there have been significant advances that allow us to hope for a Honduran solution to a Honduran crisis,” José Miguel Insulza told reporters yesterday. And, as La Tribuna reports in its “Minuto a Minuto” side bar, Mr. Zelaya’s own spokesperson has now come out and said there is “100%” consensus between the two sides of the current crisis, adding they’ve now entered the phase of “political validation.”

Meanwhile, in most Honduran papers this morning the potential end to the crisis is not even the top story as Honduras also qualified for the World Cup Wednesday. The still de facto president, Roberto Micheletti, said the country should celebrate Thursday, declaring the day a national holiday. Would this be Mr. Micheletti’s last presidential decree? Only time will tell.

[Two further notes on Honduras. I wrote yesterday about a supposed “UN” report that seemed to legitimize the ouster of Mel Zelaya in June and was subsequently publicized in many Honduran papers. The Spokesperson for the Sec. General issued a statement yesterday in response, calling the report “highly misleading.” “The Department of Political Affairs routinely receives reports and analyses of this type from consultants, academics and other experts. But its views are strictly in line with that outlined in the General Assembly Resolution,” the UN maintains. More on the matter by Rosemary Joyce at her blog. And finally the AP writes this morning that Honduran police are saying drug trafficking has increased through their country since the U.S. limited military cooperation following the June coup].

Around the region this morning:

· CNN continues to report from Colombia on violence in that country, this time sitting down for interviews with a number of “hit men/sicarios” in Medellin.

· The AP reports that the Mexican Supreme Court ruled Wednesday that the governor of the state of Oaxaca is responsible for human rights abuses committed during 2006 protests that left at least a dozen people dead. According to the news service, the ruling, however, has no binding consequences for Oaxaca Gov. Ulises Ruiz.

· Also from Mexico, the LA Times has a report on migration through Central America to Mexico. The paper writes: “Church and human rights groups say the migrants passing through [Mexico] are falling prey to kidnappers, extortionists and killers while the Mexican government does little to protect them. The national Human Rights Commission says it has recorded, in the last three years, 10,000 kidnappings of migrants, who are most frequently seized by predatory gangs who demand money from the victims' families in their home countries.”

· The Miami Herald has news on further U.S.-Cuba developments. The Spanish language “Nuevo Herald” writes “Cuba recently gave a top State Department official a long-blocked permission to visit dual U.S.-Cuban citizens jailed on the island -- but it did not accept a U.S. offer to relax travel restrictions on each other's diplomats.” The paper calls the moves an example of “both the opportunities and limits for improved relations facing the new governments of Barack Obama and Raúl Castro.”

· And finally, also in the MH, an opinion by Bernice Robertson of the International Crisis Group calls on the UN to form a more coherent strategy that links “international stabilization efforts with support for development and economic growth” in Haiti. The UN recently renewed its peacekeeping mission in the country, but according to Robertson, the international body must seek a more “integrated mission.” “Despite the welcome changes in the mandate, the Security Council should have better used its unique opportunity on Tuesday to rigorously link stabilization and development on a single agenda in Haiti, by strengthening the U.N. country team's integration with MINUSTAH.”

Wednesday, October 14, 2009

Micheletti and Zelaya Negotiators Reach 90% Agreement as One Zelaya Rep. Resigns

After a long weekend break, the “Guaymuras Dialogue” restarted Tuesday morning in Tegucigalpa and by the end of the day, reports from both sides of the negotiating table indicated that agreement on “90%” of the issues under debate had been reached (some are reporting this represents agreement on 7 of 8 points under consideration, while others say 90% represents agreement on 7 of 12 points). Thus, it would seem that when meetings commence at 9am local time today, all that remains on the table is a debate over the reinstatement of Mel Zelaya to the presidency—the most contentious point of all. On this issue, La Tribuna reports that the delegation representing Roberto Micheletti plans to first present a counterproposal to the reinstatement of Mr. Zelaya, as is currently outlined in the Oscar Arias-brokered “San José Accords.” Speaking with the press Tuesday, one Zelaya representative, Victor Meza, remarked that “The reinstatement of President Zelaya has been under consideration since the first day of negotiation, but everything will depend on today’s negotiations. In the present moment I cannot get ahead of myself because I do not know what we’re going to receive from those who represent Mr. Micheletti.” Nevertheless, Meza spoke with rare optimism Tuesday, saying “there’s a cordial and pleasant negotiating spirit in the talks, and we’re optimistic that we’ll be able to hand the country back through an acceptable political and legal agreement.” And even Mr. Zelaya, very pessimistic about the trajectory of talks in recent days, has begun to offer small hints of optimism. “I simply do not trust him [Micheletti], but there is always hope,” says Zelaya. “God exists and so do miracles.”

For his part, Meza also reiterated Tuesday that Mr. Zelaya had agreed not to push forward with the idea of holding a Constituent Assembly. Indeed, it was this issue which led to a partial fracture within the Zelaya camp. Juan Barahona, a social movement leader and active member of the National Front Against the Coup, said he could no longer participate in talks after Mr. Zelaya conceded on this point. And Mr. Barahona was immediately replaced by lawyer Rodil Rivera. Barahona insisted, however, that his resignation did not signify a personal break with Mr. Zelaya. “I didn’t sign because I am not in agreement. We are never going to stop promoting a Constitutional Assembly. But we continue support President Zelaya.” [Nevertheless, business elites, particularly Adolfo Facussé, said they were glad Mr. Barahona stepped down Tuesday. And “Honduras Coup 2009,” Rosemary Joyce has more on why Barahona’s resignation does not necessarily represent a breakdown of popular support for Mr. Zelaya]. In addition, El Faro reports that Tuesday talks brought agreement around a proposal to form a commission that would investigate the facts surrounding the June 28 ouster of President Zelaya, as outlined in the San José Accords (according to the Arias plan the Inter-American Human Rights Institute would be charged with conducting such an investigation). And AFP writes that other points of agreement include 1. Having the military come under the authority of the electoral commission until elections are held and 2. Asking the international community to drop those sanctions placed on Honduras after the coup. This is in addition to agreements rejecting amnesty for both sides and an agreement on forming a national unity government.

Finally, there is also mention this morning in Honduran papers of a second study, similar to the one conducted by the Law Library at the Library of Congress, which allegedly concludes the June 28 ouster of Mel Zelaya was “constitutional and in accord with Honduran laws.” The study was produced by the Department of Political Affairs at the United Nations, reports indicate, but I’ve yet to see it mentioned elsewhere.

Around the region today:

· Time magazine features a story this week on Iran-Venezuela relationships, asking how big a concern should Venezuela be? According to Johanna Mendelson Forman, a senior associate for the Americas at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington, D.C., “it's still too early to tell what Venezuela is really doing.”

· The AP writes that the Binational Task Force on the United States-Mexico Border, made up of both U.S. and Mexican officials, has concluded that the United States should reinstate a Clinton-era ban on assault weapons to prevent such guns from reaching Mexican drug cartels. Other recommendations from the study group include restructuring Mexico's law enforcement operations to create a counterpart to the U.S. Border Patrol, increasing U.S. assistance to Mexico to build up law enforcement and reducing demand for drugs in the United States through more treatment programs.

· The Miami Herald writes that, in the face of an economic recession, the Cuban government has “scaled back” its socialist economic policies in order to “save itself.” Changes have included restructuring the agricultural sector and rethinking policies like “deep subsidies for everyone.”

· BBC World reports on the training of some 1000 new security officials in Venezuela who, on Tuesday, became part of a new national police body in the country.

· And CNN reports on drug violence in Medellin, Colombia apparently being sparked by the arrest of older drug lords in the city and a power vacuum which has followed.

Tuesday, October 13, 2009

Micheletti-Zelaya Talks Resume Today

Official talks between representatives of ousted President Mel Zelaya and the de facto government of Roberto Michelleti are set to resume today in Tegucigalpa after a weekend recess. As reported yesterday, the two sides made progress on a number of substantive issues late last week, including around the issue of amnesty [there will currently be done] and the formation of a unity government. Now, however, discussions will turn to the biggest issue dividing the two sides: the reinstatement of Mel Zelaya as president. Micheletti [profiled by Reuters this morning here] has been unwilling to budge on this point over the last three plus months, and as AFP reported yesterday, Zelaya warned observers that Tuesday could be yet another “let down” for those eagerly awaiting a resolution to the Honduran crisis. “It’s going to be an essential day of dialogue to find out if this will all be resolved, but I don’t have much confidence,” Zelaya told the news agency yesterday. “I believe the coup regime will continue to deny the resolutions of the OAS and the international community.” Such remarks on the part of Mr. Zelaya—including placing a deadline of Oct. 15 on the current round of talks—have been criticized by some political analysts and backers of the de facto regime speaking with pro-Micheletti papers in Honduras. “The deadline given by the Zelayistas totally distorts the process of dialogue that should be flexible, coherent and done in good faith. Setting an ultimatum generates uncertainty,” lawyer and analyst Raul Pineda Alvardo recently told El Heraldo, for example.

Meanwhile, while many Zelaya supporters say there will be a new call for protests if Mel Zelaya is not restored to power by the end of the week, so too are certain sectors of the business community threatening to strike if Mr. Zelaya is reinstated. In Southern Honduras, the president of the Cámara de Comercio e Industrias del Sur (CCIS), Mario Hernán Argeñal, tells La Tribuna restoring Zelaya to power would be “counterproductive.” Also, Reuters has a new report this morning on human rights abuses that have occurred in Honduras since the June 28 coup. The news service says human rights groups have attributed at least 10 deaths to the coup regime crackdowns [the government continues to say that just three people have died in protests]. And the Honduran human rights group Cofadeh, whose own offices were attacked with tear gas by security forces two days after Zelaya’s return, has documented “numerous reports of police firing guns in poor areas of Tegucigalpa,” often occurring during evening curfew.

Finally, there was an article in Tiempo Sunday that is worth reading in full. In the piece, an Afro-Honduran community leader speaks with the paper and discusses the problems of marginalization, poverty, and social exclusion which remain endemic in Honduras. “We reiterate our condemnation of the coup and we call for national reconciliation, for a reform of electoral laws and for the convening of a plebiscite so that the citizenry can decide on a new constitution,” says Céleo Alvarez Casildo. The possibility that such a reform process might have begun was used to justify the ouster of Zelaya in late June. And while Zelaya has said he would not advocate a constitutional assembly should he be reinstated, the issue still appears to resonate deeply with many who have supported the ousted leader over the last three and a half months.

Around the region this morning:

· The AP reports that world-famous Cuban blogger, Yoani Sanchez, is not being allowed to travel to New York to receive a journalism award from Columbia University. Cuban authorities earlier denied Sanchez permission to fly to Madrid to accept the Ortega y Gasset Prize in digital journalism for the creation of her blog “Generacion Y”, which gets more than 1 million hits per month.

· Also, on Cuba, in the Miami Herald there is a report on a series of congressional bills being discussed that would open up US-Cuba travel. If passed, “There would be an explosion of contacts between Americans and Cubans . . . that would almost overshadow what the two governments are doing,” says Phil Peters, a Cuba expert with the D.C.-based Lexington Institute.

· The New York Times reported yesterday on the closure of a state-run electric company that has provided power to much of Mexico City. The company, Luz y Fuerza del Centro, was said to have been operating “inefficiently.” The closure has set off massive labor protests led by the Mexican Electrical Workers Union.

· As Spain’s El País reports, indigenous protests and roadblocks in Guatemala turned violent in certain areas surrounding Guatemala City Monday after a driver shot and killed one protestor. Two other activists were seriously injured with gunshot wounds.

· El País also reports on Colombia, writing that Alvaro Uribe remains favored to win a third term as President “despite a growing number of disasters.”

· Finally, Bloomberg News writes that George Soros has announced he will invest $1 billion in clean energy technology and donate $100 million to an “environmental advisory group to aide policymakers.” According to the report, monies will be distributed through Soros’s new, San Francisco-based Climate Policy Initiative.

Monday, October 12, 2009

No Amnesty and a Unity Gov't Agreed To, But New Media Restrictions Threaten Talks

As representatives of Roberto Micheletti and Mel Zelaya prepare to head back to the negotiating table on Tuesday, there is news this weekend that new media restrictions (mentioned briefly last week) have now gone into effect in Honduras. According to the AP, the latest Micheletti decree “threatens broadcasters with closure for airing reports that ‘attack national security,’” and comes after the OAS released a statement last week calling on the de facto government to allow the operations of two media outlets (Radio Global and Canal 36) to resume. The new measures also come after a Mr. Micheletti revoked a more far-reaching order which had suspended civil liberties in the country after Mel Zelaya’s return to Tegucigalpa. “We thought that when the (civil liberties) decree was revoked, the equipment would be returned, but that has not happened,” Yesenia Herculano, an activist with Honduras' Committee for Free Expression, told the AP last week.

Many Zelaya backers have already said the new measures could negatively impact the on-going “Guaymuras Talks” which have made some positive progress in recent days. AFP talks with one Zelaya representative, Juan Barahona, who has indicated advances have been made on important issues of debate. “There’s been progress, for example there will be no amnesty [a major component of the “San Jose Accords”]…and we’ve agreed to create a national unity government,” reports Barahona. Meanwhile, Honduras’s Tiempo and others report that agreement on these major points represents “60%” consensus on the topics under debate, up from just 25% agreement earlier last week. But, rejecting amnesty and agreeing to create a unity government still remain dependent on the reinstatement of Mel Zelaya to the presidency, says Barahona, “the central issue of the conflict,” as he calls it. According to another leader of the National Resistance, Rafael Alegría, if there is no agreement on the reinstatement of Mr. Zelaya by October 15, the anti-coup organizing committee plans to “call for civil disobedience” against the Micheletti regime and “reject the electoral process completely.”

In other major news late last week, a group of UN experts expressed their worries about “the increased use of mercenaries in Honduras” since the June 28 coup, an issue Colombia’s El Timepo had reported on a number of weeks ago. CNN reports the following: “the U.N. panel said it received reports that 40 former Colombian paramilitaries had been hired to protect properties and individuals in Honduras since the June 28 coup that ousted President Jose Manuel Zelaya. The panel also heard reports that 120 mercenaries from various Latin American countries had been contracted to support the government of Roberto Micheletti, who was installed as president hours after Zelaya's removal.” [Micheletti denied that paramilitaries were being contracted by the government from Colombia for such tasks, says El Heraldo.] The U.N. group also accused the Honduran government of indiscriminately using “sound-generating devices against Zelaya and his supporters at the embassy,” while Amnesty International demanded the Micheletti regime “allow opposition journalists to broadcast” during the on-going negotiation process.

Also, while the lead OAS negotiator in Honduras, John Biehl, adds his voice to those speaking with much optimism this weekend, Reuters has an interesting piece that examines the effectiveness of the OAS, in general, in the wake of the Honduras crisis. According to the Dialogue’s Michael Shifter, the organization’s “condemnation of the coup was positive, because the OAS had remained silent in many other situations. But at the moment of seeking a solution and overcoming the crisis, [the OAS] showed its weaknesses that are basically a reflection of the disorder in the Latin American political landscape.” In the pro-Micheletti El Heraldo a weekend piece says that current talks between Micheletti and Zelaya representatives may be fracturing into three camps as many Zelaya backers still demand a constitutional assembly to rewrite the Honduran constitution. In opinions/editorials this weekend, the New York Times writes that Roberto Micheletti is “listening to the wrong people,” and the Times declares: “President Zelaya must be reinstated to office. Nothing else will do.” And after giving a spot to lobbyist Lanny Davis last weekend, the Wall Street Journal gives Sen. Jim DeMint an opportunity to write about his Honduras trip on Saturday. DeMint reports: “After visiting Tegucigalpa last week and meeting with a cross section of leaders from Honduras's government, business community, and civil society, I can report there is no chaos there. There is, however, chaos to spare in the Obama administration's policy toward our poor and loyal allies in Honduras.” It gets better. “As all strong democracies do after cleansing themselves of usurpers, Honduras has moved on… In a day packed with meetings, we met only one person in Honduras who opposed Mr. Zelaya's ouster, who wishes his return, and who mystifyingly rejects the legitimacy of the November elections: U.S. Ambassador Hugo Llorens.” And finally, a priceless photo from AFP of Mel Zelaya’s Brazilian Embassy office, cowboy hat included.

Around the region this weekend:

· The AP reports that the Argentine Senate overwhelmingly approved a new, and somewhat controversial, media law which was quickly signed into law by President Cristina Kirchner. The AP writes: “The new law preserves two-thirds of the radio and TV spectrum for noncommercial stations, and requires channels to use more Argentine content. It also forces Grupo Clarin, the country's leading media company, to sell off many of its properties.”

· The Washington Post reports from Venezuela on President Hugo Chávez’s campaign against the sport of golf in his country.

· The New York Times has a piece on the Chevron vs. Ecuador pollution case which gets more bizarre by the week. “Ever since the oil giant released videos in August that were secretly taped by two businessmen who seemed to have the ambition of feasting off the expected $27 billion in damages sought, Ecuadorean officials and Chevron have accused each other of gross improprieties, including espionage.”

· Spain’s El País reports that the election of 3 Supreme Court judges in Guatemala has been annulled after the U.N. raised questions about the transparency of the election process. Also in Guatemala, another round of attacks on security officials took the life of one police officer and wounded six others.

· The LA Times features a fascinating story this morning on “narco lawyers” in Mexico (those who defend drug lords in Mexican courts), increasingly the target of rival drug gangs.

· Finally, a few opinions. In the WSJ, Mary O’Grady speaks with former Sec. of State George Schultz about his problems with drug interdiction. And in the MH, Bernard Aronson attacks Sen. Jim DeMint’s one-man blockade of Latin American diplomats in the Senate Foreign Relations Committee. He writes: “Neither nominee [Valenzuela or Shannon] can take office, however, because a single senator, James DeMint of South Carolina, has put their nominations on indefinite ‘hold’ because he disagrees with the administration's policy toward Honduras.”

Friday, October 9, 2009

25% Agreement Reached Between Coup Gov't and Zelaya Backers; But Still Much to Decide

Face to face talks between representatives of de facto President Roberto Micheletti and ousted President Manuel Zelaya are set to continue Friday at Tegucigalpa’s Clarion Hotel, even after a delegation of Latin and North American diplomats failed to facilitate a solution to the Honduran crisis during Wednesday talks. Mayra Mejia, one of Zelaya's representatives says the two sides will stay at the negotiating table through the weekend, and perhaps longer, if necessary. According to the AP, Mejia went on to say the two sides had reached agreement on 25 percent of the issues under debate, although she wouldn't disclose more specifics. Reuters reports that another Zelaya, negotiator, Juan Barahona, has hinted that Mr. Zelaya’s reinstatement as President still remains the most contentious issue between the two sides. “We are very pessimistic. We don't see any positive feeling in the position of the coup leaders. They are not considering the restitution of Zelaya,” Barahona recently remarked. CNN also reports that Mr. Barahona and Vilma Morales, a third Zelaya representative, have indicated that the Micheletti regime believes all of the points in the proposed accord should be debated while the ousted government “wants agreement on Zelaya’s return to the presidency before discussing the rest of the document.”

The OAS’s quick departure from Tegucigalpa may strike some as strange but according to Costa Rican foreign minister, Bruno Stagno, it is imperative that a solution to the crisis be “exclusively Honduran.” “This is a divided family and they have to reconcile,” Stagno said Thursday. Peter Kent, Canada’s minister of state for the Americas, insisted that the OAS visit was not a failure in any way. “We had both sides speak to each other in a positive way. This was really only the first step in a much longer process.” In Washington, D.C., Rep. Jan Schakowsky warns (and Honduras’s La Tribuna reports), that a failure of OAS-initiated talks would only “prolong the crisis and isolation of the country [of Honduras].

Like the New York Times yesterday, the Washington Post today looks at the coup regime’s band of close friends in high places. Mary Beth Sheridan writes, “the de facto Honduran government and its allies have spent at least $600,000 [the NYT reported just $400,000 yesterday] on public-relations experts and lobbyists from both parties, including Lanny Davis, former special counsel to President Bill Clinton” [More on Lanny Davis later]. According to one anonymous U.S. official, the words of various pro-Micheletti congressmen and senators “gives [the de facto government] this hope that you can hang on. It’s not helpful.” And according to CFR’s Julia Sweig the actions of some Republicans goes well beyond Latin American, given the fact that many, like Sen. Jim DeMint, have no prior interest in Latin American affairs. “It’s about the Republicans using what they can to attack the administration. It’s definitely bigger than Latin America.” DeMint has denied such allegations, however. “This is not about Obama. This is about foreign policy,” he tells the Post.

In other Honduras-related items this morning, the aforementioned Lanny Davis is given an op-ed slot at the Wall Street Journal today. The lobbyist (paid some $350,000 to represent Honduran business interests, according to the Post’s reporting), argues the following: “A successful resolution to the Guaymuras Dialogue should ensure: the resignation, after the election, of Mr. Micheletti and renunciation by Mr. Zelaya of his intention to be restored as president; the succession, as provided by the constitution, of a caretaker president between election day and inauguration day; a conciliation government representing all segments of civil society; and most importantly, binding commitments to a series of constitutional and economic reforms aimed at more equitable distribution of wealth.” He goes on: “If Mr. Zelaya refuses to ‘resign’ or renounce his intention to be restored, which is a distinct possibility, one would hope that the U.S. and other nations of the OAS and EU would no longer feel compelled to insist on his reinstatement. They should then recognize the election of the new president, and the crisis would truly be over.”

The LA Times, in a Friday editorial, has a different argument. “U.S. and OAS officials must do everything in their power to persuade the Micheletti camp to relent and allow Zelaya's return. And they must convince Zelaya that there would be zero tolerance for any attempt to stay in power,” the paper argues. They add that one idea being floated around is the creation of a “constitutional requirement that control over the military pass to the Supreme Electoral Council a month before elections” to quell coup regime fears that Zelaya might manipulate the military before scheduled elections.

At The Nation, Greg Grandin looks to what might come after the crisis, writing: “the coup--along with Zelaya's surprise return--has created a lose-lose situation for Honduran elites. If they yield to international pressure and negotiate Zelaya's symbolic restoration, it would legitimize the November elections but would also embolden the left and discredit the coup plotters--that is, nearly all of Honduras' governing class. If they force Zelaya back into exile, arrest him or keep him holed up in the Brazilian Embassy, then the popular movement that has gained momentum over the past three months will demand a constitutional convention as the only solution to re-establish legitimacy. In other words, the very issue that served as the spark of the crisis--Zelaya's attempt to build support for a constituent assembly to reform Honduras' notoriously undemocratic charter--may be the only way to settle it.”

And Rosemary Joyce reports on a new decree announced Monday by the Micheletti regime to once again limit the free media in Honduras.

Around the region today:

· The AP reports that Venezuela and Great Britain have reaffirmed counter-narcotics cooperation. The two countries signed a memorandum of understanding on the topic and Chris Bryant, of the British Foreign Office, “congratulated [Hugo] Chavez's government on stepping up control over ports and airports and destroying clandestine drug labs on the border with Colombia.”

· The mayor of the small Mexican border town of Palomas was kidnapped and murdered this week. According to the AP, the victim, Estanislao Garcia Santelis, “had long complained about the drug traffickers and migrant smugglers active around Palomas.”

· Multiple attacks on police officers in Guatemala have taken the lives of at least two and wounded three others. Officials say the acts were retaliation for security crackdowns on gangs in the country.

· And in the Miami Herald Andres Oppenheimer comments on Mexico, saying it’s not economics which is the country’s most pressing problem, but rather politics. “Mexico's biggest problem is that President Felipe Calderón's government has its hands tied and can do very little to solve these problems. Because of an outdated political system, Mexico has a weak president who can't pass meaningful reforms through Congress.” He goes on to argue for a major reform that introduces a runoff election in Mexican politics or creates the job of a prime minister.


Thursday, October 8 2009, State Dept. Press Briefing Re: Honduras

QUESTION: Can we go to Honduras or --

MR. KELLY: Honduras, sure.

QUESTION: It seems by the reports that the Organizational States presence there is not getting any results by the moment. I don’t know if you have more updates. And also --

MR. KELLY: Well --

QUESTION: -- it seems, I don’t know, to me – and also I was reading some reports in so many countries of Latin America that the – it’s surprising that you have there in that meeting the secretary of the hemisphere – acting secretary of the hemisphere Thomas Shannon?

MR. KELLY: Assistant Secretary.

QUESTION: Assistant Secretary. And Micheletti is also keeping his word of not changing nothing. So it’s a very strange situation. What’s going on? He doesn’t want to sign the San Jose.

MR. KELLY: Right.

QUESTION: And they go there with this mission of – very high-profile --

MR. KELLY: Right.

QUESTION: -- five minister of external relations of five countries – Canada, the U.S. – and he’s still maintaining that position. What’s --

MR. KELLY: Yeah. Well, actually, I would take issue with your characterization. I understand that there was a positive tone in the meetings, that there was a meeting – I think for the first time – a meeting mediated by the OAS ministers between the two sides. And I think that’s important. I think it’s important that they’ve initiated a direct dialogue.

And the ministers will leave, or perhaps have already left, but they’re leaving behind an OAS secretariat to continue to help facilitate this direct dialogue. And I think that’s important that they’re able to establish this face-to-face meeting between the two sides. So I don’t want to raise expectations too high here or anything, but I think it was a little more productive than you seem to characterize it.

QUESTION: I’m sorry, go ahead.

QUESTION: I just wanted to make a follow-up. Are you aware of a proposal to bring government junta to Honduras, try to solve the political crisis there? Are you aware of that?

MR. KELLY: I’m not aware of that. The main thing for us is that the two sides break this impasse, and by this direct meeting, we have some hope that maybe they are moving towards this. But the main thing is for them both to agree with the facilitation of the OAS to some kind of lasting solution to this crisis. I mean, the people of Honduras deserve nothing less.

QUESTION: And Mr. Crowley said yesterday that Venezuela needs to cooperate in a more constructive way in the region. What did he mean by that? It was regarding Honduras, or could you be more specific?

MR. KELLY: (Laughter.) I agree with my boss that Honduras needs to play a constructive role. We’re calling on all the countries in the region to play a --

QUESTION: Venezuela.

QUESTION: Not Honduras.

QUESTION: Venezuela.

QUESTION: Venezuela.

MR. KELLY: Venezuela.

QUESTION: Okay.

MR. KELLY: That Venezuela needs to play a constructive role. This is an important crisis that we need to resolve, that the – I think the region is moving in a good direction, in moving towards a more inclusive and democratic political system in these countries. And we would hope that Venezuela would play a more productive role.

I’ll take --

QUESTION: Just on Honduras or --

MR. KELLY: Oh, in general, but also in Honduras. And I’m going to take one more question, because we have Assistant Secretary Gordon waiting for us.

QUESTION: Well, what do you see as a productive role?

MR. KELLY: Sorry?

QUESTION: Can you give an example of what do you mean by a more productive role for --

MR. KELLY: For Venezuela, you mean?

QUESTION: Yeah.

MR. KELLY: Well, I think – first of all, I think that they need to open up their own democracy. They need to stop intimidation of media. They need to encourage more debate, more political debate within Venezuela, and play a more productive role in the region. I think that Mr. Crowley mentioned that Venezuela should concentrate more on its – in its region and not pay so much attention to what’s going on in Iran and other countries.

Last question to Jill. Go ahead.

QUESTION: Ian, this has been dragging on for so long. Why are we not to draw the conclusion that it’s dragging on because the U.S. won’t do anything – really do anything about this because there is significant support for the members of the coup, business connections with the United States, conservative organizations that support the coup that do not like Zelaya. So why are we not supposed to, you know, draw some conclusion that it’s simply foot-dragging on the part of this Administration?

MR. KELLY: Boy, I don’t see this Administration as dragging its feet at all. I mean, we have had a very consistent principle here of supporting the idea of a democratic and constitutional order, that you had a coup where the democratically elected leader was (inaudible). But in the final analysis, this is not about us. This is really about (inaudible) of us supporting a multilateral process, of supporting the OAS in its efforts to try and facilitate a solution.

Thursday, October 8, 2009

Micheletti to OAS: "You Don't Know the Truth and Don't Want to Know It!"

Déjà vu? 1) De facto government of Roberto Micheletti shows signs that it may be willing to loosen its grip on power. 2) The OAS arrives in Central America for highly publicized meetings with Mr. Micheletti and ousted President Mel Zelaya. 3) Disappointment follows as Mr. Micheletti refuses to budge in the face of international pressure. And…repeat. Was Wednesday yet another showing of the same old tragedy? The AP’s coverage of Wednesday’s “Guaymuros Talks” would make it appear so. “Honduras' coup-installed leader resisted calls by diplomats from across the hemisphere to reinstate ousted President Manuel Zelaya, at one point angrily telling the visitors they “‘don't know the truth or don't want to know it,’” the wire service writes today. Reuters adds that “Police and soldiers armed with clubs and automatic weapons chased away demonstrators who shouted ‘Help us, OAS,’” just before the talks were to begin. Two people were injured, one by a rubber bullet and another by a gas canister, according to a local hospital. However, meetings did commence, first behind closed doors with representatives of both Mr. Zelaya and Mr. Micheletti [AP photos reveal that talks with Mr. Zelaya occurred in his Brazilian embassy “bedroom,” next to his inflatable bed] and later in public. It was the public meetings which the AP calls “a televised confrontation between Micheletti and the foreign envoys in the presidential palace.” Mr. Micheletti, “his voice bristling with rage,” went so far as to tell the OAS diplomats they must “reflect on the damage [they] are doing to a country that has done nothing to [them].” As the LA Times reports, the point of greatest contention for the coup government is whether or not Mr. Zelaya will be allowed to return to power. “We are not afraid of the United States, nor of the State Department, nor of Mexico or Brazil. But we are afraid and panicked when it comes to Zelaya,” roared Micheletti.

Nevertheless, OAS Sec. General, José Miguel Insulza, the head of the visiting delegation, insisted the inter-American group of 12 foreign ministers, plus U.S. Ass’t. Sec. of State, Tom Shannon, was not in Tegucigalpa for a debate with Mr. Micheletti. Rather they were seeking “concrete solutions to a situation that cannot be prolonged.” In this spirit, Insulza presented a proposal to both sides which would restore Zelaya as the head of a unity government until his term ends in January and would offer amnesty to both the coup leaders and the deposed president [Mr. Zelaya would also have to give up his attempt to hold a constitutional referendum, in the mark of the San Jose Accords of July].

The New York Times reporting on Honduras this morning looks at the de facto regime’s intense lobbying campaign in Washington, D.C. which has cost approx. $400,000 thus far, according to lobbying registration records. The campaign has “involved law firms and public relations agencies with close ties to Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton (Lanny Davis) and Senator John McCain (John Timmons),” write Ginger Thompson and Ron Nixon, as well numerous individuals best known for their role in the Central American dirty wars of the 1980s (among them, Otto Reich, Daniel Fisk, and Roger Noriega). In the words of the Times, these men “view Honduras as the principal battleground in a proxy fight with Cuba and Venezuela, which they characterize as threats to stability in the region in language similar to that once used to describe the designs of the Soviet Union.” Testifying before Congress in July, Mr. Reich remarked that “What happens in Honduras may one day be seen as either the high-water mark of Hugo Chávez’s attempt to undermine democracy in this hemisphere or as a green light to the spread of Chavista authoritarianism.” [In an email to members of Congress after the coup, Reich wrote the following as well: “We should rejoice that one of the self-proclaimed 21st Century socialist allies of Chávez has been legally deposed by his own countrymen. According to Chris Sabatini of America’s Quarterly, “There’s been a leadership vacuum on Honduras in the administration, and these are the people who’ve filled it. They haven’t gotten a lot of support, but enough to hold the administration’s policy hostage for now.”

Finally, in other Honduras news, the AP reports on 12 indigenous Hondurans seeking exile in Guatemala out of fear that they are being pursued by Honduran security forces for their participation in anti-coup demonstrations [a colleague of mine recently remarked that you know things are bad when indigenous activists are asking for asylum in Guatemala, of all places!]. Pro-Micheletti news outlets in Honduras are reporting a very different tone in Wednesday’s talks. La Tribuna says OAS delegates showed their “satisfaction” with the first day of meetings. And El Heraldo calls Mr. Micheletti’s presentation to OAS delegates simply “energetic” [I recommend reading the whole article for many, many more Micheletti quotes. And Foreign Policy’s “The Cable” talks with Sen. Richard Lugar, ranking member of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, about Sen. Jim DeMint’s trip south. Lugar said he supports the GOP trips to Honduras but not DeMint's holds on diplomats to Latin America. “On balance it may be helpful [for members of Congress to travel to Honduras]. Clearly there was an impasse there,” remarked Sen. Lugar. “Our foreign policy has tried to be mindful and consistent with the OAS and this has led really to our having really no representation in the country.” In fact, Lugar added that he himself intended to visit with de facto President Roberto Micheletti before the State Department pulled Micheletti’s visa.

In other news, the AP reports on a militant attack on a Colombian prison in Arauca Wednesday which freed a guerrilla leader accused of kidnapping two American journalists. The jailbreak occurred less than six weeks after Colombia’s Supreme Court denied a request from the United States to extradite Mr. Giraldo.

The Wall Street Journal speculates on a possible future political career for the head of Brazil’s Central Bank, Henrique Meirelles, a potential running mate for Lula da Silva’s chosen successor, Dilma Rousseff. The paper writes: “the notion of a central banker laying the groundwork for a potential political campaign while still on the job would create enormous controversy in the U.S. and other major economies, where the political independence of a central bank is crucial for its credibility. While some former Brazilian central-bank officials have criticized Mr. Meirelles's move, controversy surrounding his possible run has been confined mainly to a small group of economists who follow the institution.”

And in the Miami Herald, Marifeli Perez-Stable writes that the U.S. and Cuba are “taking baby steps toward each other.” Revisiting moments of thawing between the two countries, she says Cuba policy (both for and against the embargo) is now bipartisan, and argues, “so far so good, but I hope a lot more eyebrows -- here and there -- are raised.”

Wednesday State Dept. Briefing Re: Honduras

QUESTION: Okay. What’s Tom Shannon up to?

MR. KELLY: Tom Shannon.

QUESTION: Any interesting travel plans?

MR. KELLY: Yes.

QUESTION: He’s there, isn’t he?

MR. KELLY: He’s there. He is in Tegucigalpa. He is participating in the OAS mission of foreign ministers. Had arrived this morning and is scheduled to meet with all parties that can play a role in resolving the crisis. It is headed by Secretary General Insulza, plus 12 other foreign ministers and Mr. Shannon.

And of course, our goal is to help – or I shouldn’t say our goal. The goal of the mission is to encourage a meaningful dialogue between the parties that would lead to the implementation of the San Jose Accord.

QUESTION: What happened to your policy of limiting high-level contacts between your officials and the Micheletti government?

MR. KELLY: Yeah. I think our focus here is trying to get this internal dialogue going, and the way to do that is to have the two parties – talk to the two parties involved.

QUESTION: Yeah. So --

MR. KELLY: So we’re willing to talk with anybody who’s – who can advance this goal.

QUESTION: So you’ve backed down on this policy of not --

MR. KELLY: I don’t know that we’ve backed down on it. I mean, our goal is a resolution of this crisis. And so within this context of the OAS mission, we – I anticipate that they will sit down and talk with Micheletti and Zelaya.

QUESTION: Isn’t that meeting – I thought that meeting was actually scheduled for – I thought that there was a meeting scheduled among the OAS delegation and Micheletti today.

MR. KELLY: I think that’s probably – I know they’re – they arrived this morning, they had meetings this afternoon, and I think they leave around midday tomorrow.

QUESTION: Can you – is it possible for you to get us a readout from Assistant Secretary Shannon on how the meetings went?

MR. KELLY: I’ll see what I can do.

QUESTION: Thank you.

MR. KELLY: Thanks.

Wednesday, October 7, 2009

Another Round of Dialogue: "Guaymuras Talks" to Begin Today

Delegates from over 10 Latin and North American countries are today arriving in Tegucigalpa to begin yet another round of negotiations between advisers to ousted President Manuel Zelaya and the de facto regime of Roberto Micheletti. In the words of Mr. Micheletti, this time the talks would begin with a “new spirit,” while addressing the main issues of dispute over the San Jose Accord (particularly “powers of the state” and the issue of “amnesty”). The AP quotes Micheletti Tuesday saying, “To consolidate political stability and normalize our country's relations with the international community, I believe the time is right to intensify the national dialogue.” But, as Reuters adds, Mr. Micheletti and Mr. Zelaya will not actually meet with each other face-to-face on Wednesday. Instead, Mel Zelaya plans to send three new faces to the negotiating table—Victor Meza, Mayra Mejía, and Juan Barahona—replacing Milton Jiménez, Silvia Ayala and Patricia Rodas (the Zelaya team also includes five other members who form part of the “popular resistance” movement in Honduras). For its part, the Micheletti regime has also mixed up its negotiating team, replacing foreign minister Carlos Lopez Contreras with lawyer Armando Aguilar Cruz who joins Arturo Corrales and Vilma Morales as representatives of the de facto government. According to El Heraldo this morning, behind today’s discussions—now being called the “Guaymuras Dialogue,”—there still remain doubts, particularly on the part of Mr. Zelaya and his followers. Speaking from the Brazilian embassy Tuesday, Zelaya called the latest OAS mission “very smooth,” adding that the OAS “must make clear its position” and not “fall for the games being played by the Micheletti regime.”

Such “games” include continuous delays on the part of the Micheletti regime. As Rosemary Joyce at “Honduras Coup 2009” and Reuters both note, the latest such delay comes after Mr. Micheletti rescinded a state of emergency on Monday, but has yet to have the announcement published in the official record, “La Gaceta.” Thus, says RAJ, the decree PCM-M-016-2009, still remains in effect and pro-Zelaya media outlets remain shuttered. [RAJ also has interesting new poll numbers from late August that show 52.7% of Hondurans opposing the coup of June 28.]

In the New York Times this morning, Elisabeth Malkin reports on an issue Mary Anastasia O’Grady discussed in her Monday WSJ opinion column—the troubling words of pro-Zelaya Radio Globo host David Romero Ellner. In late September, Mr. Ellner, on air, said: “There are times when I ask myself if Hitler was or was not correct in finishing with that race with the famous Holocaust. If there is a people that do damage in this country, they are Jewish, they are Israelis.” Ellner has since asked for forgiveness for what he called such “stupidity,” and Mel Zelaya has attempted to distance himself from the comments, noting he appointed four Jewish cabinet members during his term.

And, in interviews in various publications, three individuals very much involved in the Honduran crisis give their latest thoughts on where things currently stand. Reported in La Tribuna, Lula da Silva again demanded the return of Zelaya but added amnesty for the coup perpetrators should follow: “There is only one thing that is not working in Honduras. There is a person in the presidency who should not be there. If he leaves power and normalcy returns, if Manuel Zelaya is permitted to hold elections, there will be amnesty because the international community wants Honduras to live well.” In Tiempo, U.S. Amb. Hugo Llorens says U.S. Ass’t Sec. of State for the Western Hemisphere, Tom Shannon, will be joining the OAS delegation arriving Wednesday, illustrating the U.S. commitment to resolving the crisis now [Llorens also insisted the Obama administration does not share the position of various Republican congressional members who have visited Tegucigalpa in recent days. Three of those members, Ileana Ros-Lehtinen and Mario and Lincoln Diaz-Balart returned to the U.S. yesterday demanding November elections be recognized]. And, presidential candidate/frontrunner Porfirio Lobo speaks with Spain’s El País. In the interview, Lobo insists he will form a unity government to heal a country that is deeply divided, if elected. But he also discusses how he believes it was Mel Zelaya who tore the country apart. As Lobo tells it: “I attended a meeting in his (Zelaya’s) office in May, one month before he was ousted from power. There were just three people. Zelaya, General Romeo Vásquez…and me. The general left it very clear that if [Zelaya] convened an illegal referendum, he would not be able to obey the order. He warned him…”

In other news today, the Washington Post reports on how competition from “mom and pop” marijuana farmers in the U.S. is cutting into the profits of Mexican drug cartels. The paper writes: “…Recent changes in state laws that allow the use and cultivation of marijuana for medical purposes are giving U.S. growers a competitive advantage, challenging the traditional dominance of the Mexican traffickers, who once made brands such as Acapulco Gold the standard for quality. Almost all of the marijuana consumed in the multibillion-dollar U.S. market once came from Mexico or Colombia. Now as much as half is produced domestically, often by small-scale operators who painstakingly tend greenhouses and indoor gardens to produce the more potent, and expensive, product that consumers now demand, according to authorities and marijuana dealers on both sides of the border.”

The LA Times reports from Colombia on the recruitment of indigenous youth into armed rebel groups in the country. According to a recent study conducted by the Jorge Tadeo Lozano University in Bogota (and based on some 8000 interviews), 64% of new recruits are under 14 years old and join to escape poverty and isolation. Further, nearly half of all such recruits come from indigenous backgrounds, says Natalia Springer, one of the study’s primary authors.

And finally the AP reports on newly declassified documents published by the National Security Archive this week which show “how Cuban exile and suspected terrorist Luis Posada Carriles informed on violent Miami-based efforts to attack Fidel Castro's fledgling Cuban government even as he was deeply involved in helping them.” Posada, a longtime CIA informant, was later suspected in the 1976 bombing of a Cuban jet, hotel bombings in Havana in 1997 and other crimes. He currently faces charges of immigration fraud in Texas, including lying about involvement in the Havana attacks.